Great location, good rooms, good staff, great breakfast, but noisey as hell
Good bits:
Murray Hill is a great area - easy walking distance to anything you want, but quieter and with a safe feeling.
Everything on your doorstep. Easy subway.
The hotel is well run and clean.
Excellent breakfasts.
Good size rooms - great beds with memory foam mattress - bed bug anti/free and super comfy.
Bathroom small but functional. 
Great to have a safe in the room AND a full size ironing board and iron in the room - no endless waiting for an iron to be brought up.
Plenty of hanging space and drawer space.
Bad Bits:
New York is New York and is LOUD!! Of course it’s loud so this should not be a surprise and hotels should be built to manage this…BUT This hotel seriously needs secondary glazing! So noisy without. Placed on fifth floor and moved to 9th as no chance of sleep especially with a 5am 1am 2am (you get the idea) bin truck – BUT still hard to sleep successfully
Also VERY loud aircon that only had one setting in our room, there were two actual cool settings, but both did the same = gale @ full freeze
Shame because otherwise great, but ended up coming home tired and you can’t do New York tired :O(
Seriously - you have a hotel room to sleep in, and slip should be an easy priority.