Convenient location, nice, clean rooms
We stayed here as part of a contiki tour over NYE and I was pleasantly surprised with the Skyline. I expected it to be a further walk from Times Square however it was well within walking distance. The rooms were huge and had a lovely bathroom, large bed and (at least in my room) a great view. I was on one of the higher levels so not sure if street noise was a problem on lower levels. Didn't use the pool either however we did eat at the restaurant attached one night. The food was fine but the service was slow and one meal came out cold. However I think we received a discount on our bill which was appreciated.
My only criticism was the cost of wifi. With so many hotels offering free wifi it was really a shame that wasn't offered to us. I payed something like $10 for 24 hours which would have been quite extravagant had I been staying longer than a few days.
However overall the hotel was fantastic and I definitely stay there again. Close to main attractions, restaurants, grocery stores, subways - everything you needed. Was a little more pricey than other hotels I stayed at but I wasn't disappointed with my stay!