A Needle in a Haystack
I was overwhelmed when looking for a hotel in NYC, but this was like finding a needle in a haystack. I got lucky! Quiet street. Quiet room. Comfy bed. Gorgeous decor. Helpful staff. Relaxing spa. Concierge staff that gave excellent information. It was a great way to spend 5 nights, including my birthday. 
The only con that I can say, and beware it is a selfish one, is that they knew it was my birthday and I didn't get so much as a plate of extra turndown treats. Our two favorite places on earth (The Inn at Palmetto Bluff and Walden Inn) would have left a split of bubbles or a card at least, but then again, The Surrey might assume this was a one time stay, and no need to go the extra mile.
Also, the towels and robes were poor quality - very rough and scratchy. Otherwise, we had an awesome stay.