On the fence.
Housekeeping was amazing as always. The security guard and night concierge were very friendly and helpful.
I did have a huge issue with the Sunday morning concierge, having left my debit card in side the hotel bar. There was clearly cleaning staff inside of the bar, and she refused to ask them to look around for my card. I had seen it on the floor of the bar through the window. I explained to her that I had a 12 o'clock Amtrak to catch, and she merely stated that no one would be allowed in the bar until 5 p.m.
I had to board a train to Chicago with no debit card, no cash, and couldn't even leave housekeeping (which was AMAZING) a tip. Fortunately, my card company expedited a card to a relative in Chicago.
My stay was fairly pleasant until my two hours until check-out, but that situation is really making me consider not staying at the Fenway Howard Johnson ever again.