Great first timer!
The W New York was in a great location. Everyone who worked there was greatly knowledgeable and you could tell loved working there, which is always refreshing. The room was much smaller then I thought it would be, but when you are spending most of your time outdoors, it was actually the perfect amount of space for 2 people. The beds were totally comfy, and the blackout blinds definitely helped keep the bright sunshine out! 
It was my first time in NYC, and first time in a W, and it was fantastic!