Shake, rattle and roll
I'm sure this is a great hotel — above the third floor. However, my three-night stay was on the third floor, and that meant feeling the subway going under you about every 2 to 10 minutes, depending on time of day. Also, this hotel is about two or three doors down from a fire station. So we were treated to sirens all day and night, too. The rest of the amenities were great though. Would we stay here again? You bet, on a floor above the 10th! I don't think there's a better location in the Theater District. So if you plan to see plays and perhaps stroll through Central Park, then book it. But book early so you can request one of the higher floors.