Very Good Hotel
We stayed at this hotel for 5 nights over Thanks Giving holiday. This is a very nice hotel. Our room (827) was very quiet and we had none of the issues we'd read about rooftop club noise-none. We always pack light, so the closet space worked for us. We read a lot of tough reviews about the sink & the toilet. The sink is chic and is also fine if you use the whole thing, the design makes you feel that you should use only the deep part! The toilet flush is perfectly fine, so I don't understand the bad reviews. Large button-large flush, small button...Yes, the light switches are not the North American norm, but really are self-explanatory.
Jennifer checked us in & she was very pleasant. On Thursday we asked to watch the Jets/Patriots game (Pats really laid a beating on NYJ) on the TV in the lobby with volume. The staff really tried but they couldn't do it:( They did suggest a good sports bar.
Even though we like this hotel, we won't stay at this hotel again because;
We left the Meatpacking district everyday rather than staying in the neighborhood. Besides Chelsea Market & the fantastic High Line, we found ourselves spending more time in SoHo & the village. One thing about the neighborhood-there are a lot of mom & pop diners and chic restaurants including Salinas on 9th-which is a modern(not a mom & pop), chic, high-quality tapas place-we highly recommend it.
We loved the look of the hotel lobby,but it felt like dinner lighting at all times, even at 8 AM! (we are morning people). Having said this, all the staff we dealt with really worked to take care of us-we just left the neighborhood by 10+ blocks all the time. 
The bed is AWESOME.
This is a great hotel for the young and cool crowd. It's a great place to see and be seen:)