OK but not great
This is a boutique hotel in mid-town Manhattan. Its location is great. However, my expectations were not met based on its 4-star rating and its expensive rates. The room (I got the deluxe, which is larger than the standard room) was very small and very poorly equipped. There was no dresser. The closet was very small, without shelves, and its bottom half was occupied by a small refrigeration. The lighting in the room was very dim. The mattress was OK, but did not have the "pillow-top mattress," nor the "luxurious linen," as listed on their web site. The bathroom was very small, without any counter space and had a miniature sink. The doors to the closet and to the bathroom were cheap. The desk was the size of a small vanity table. The hallway had a cheap, poorly maintained carpet, reminiscent of a college dormitory. The lobby area was a standard residential-type vestibule. 
I did like few things about this place: the iPhone docking station, the easily accessible power supply outlet by the desk, the free wi-fi, the towels, the library/meeting room, and the free coffee and espresso in the library.