Disappointing
Stayed here last week, very disappointing. 
Arrived at the Hotel to be told that we had been rebooked into a different hotel for 2 nights of our stay and would have to walk up to that hotel.
When asked why we were moved was simply told, it just says you were rebooked on the computer. I dont know why. 
Very frustrating. Had to walk up two blocks to a horrendous hotel with all our luggage and stay in a hotel with no elevator, tiny television, tiny bed and awful bathroom. 
As a result of being moved around for half the stay we obviously had to CHECKOUT of the other hotel by 10am and then check in was not until THREE PM at Broadway. 
Incredibly annoying wasting a day in New York relocating hotels, storing luggage etc etc.
Finally made it into our room and was okay. We had a private room with private bath. The only major complaint i had was the bed is quite small, no air con or heating and the light in the room was remote controlled, sounds amazing BUT it had a mind of its own and would switch on and off at all different times through the night! ~ One night in particular it turned on a 1am, then 3am and then repeatedly at at about 3.30am.
You can turn the remote control light off altogether at the wall BUT then you cannot operate the fan! Being on the fourth floor with no aircon the room gets incredibly hot even in fall. 
IF you can look beyond all these nuances the location is great and one block from a subway, wifi is free but in the lobby ONLY. Starbucks and MacDonalds a block away also have free wifi and plenty of drug stores and restaurants in the area. 
I personally wouldn't recommend staying at Broadway to any friends however the area is great to be based in for NY.