It Was GREAT
I wanted to go to NYC for a very long time and September is a very hard month for my sister and I so we decided that that was what we where going to do this year. 
We stayed at Casablanca for 3 nights and we LOVED it. Everyone there is so nice and helpful. If you need soy milk they will have it for you. They go out of their way to make your stay great and they sure did for us. I don't think there has been anywhere that I have traveled that has been so great. My sister says that I ruined it for her because now her standards are so high from staying here.
You will be right outside from where the ball drops for New Years Eve, it is safe, and walking distance to so many things. Our room was great, they leave chocolate's for you :) , robes and slippers, the breakfast is great along with the espresso maker. 
I would say that the price is well worth it and when we go again this will be the place we stay.