Great breakfast & location, average room
Stayed at Humphrey's with my wife over the President's Day Weekend. The hotel is conveniently located on Shelter Island, about 10 minutes from Downtown San Diego and adjacent to beautiful Point Loma.
We really enjoyed our stay, though we weren't incredibly impressed by the hotel room. The room itself was fine, except for the plastic mattress cover which made the bed very uncomfortable. (We removed the cover and had housekeeping take it away, which greatly improved our sleep after the first night.) The bathroom was clean, modern and of average size. Unfortunately, the décor is a bit outdated throughout the room and the walls leave something to be desired in terms of privacy.
A big bonus for us was the breakfast which was included in our room rate. The restaurant onsite was really lovely, offering harbor views and a delicious assortment of choices for breakfast, lunch and dinner.
Another big perk was that Humphrey's offers free bicycle rentals to its guests. We took advantage of this and rode bikes around Shelter Island (only drawback here - you must stay on the island) for a couple hours and took in the beautiful views.
Overall, a good place for the reasonable rate, but not something that we would recommend for anyone trying to take a romantic weekend away.