Stay here with precautions!
The hotel sits next to a closed Howard Johnsons, so the overall outward look is not appealing. The immediate area is industrial and it is very hard to find the hotel due to lack of good signage (the hotel is on a frontage road making it hard to find).
The shuttle bus is iffy; even though it was sitting there in the lot, the staff did not seem to know how to get someone to pick me up. I would give the staff a D for poor service.
The interet worked, but when it went down, the staff did not seem to know how to fix or were very unwilling to fix it (12 hours wait). I had to call the tech number, get them to call the office, and then the office would fix it! This again merits a D for poor service.
The cottage look was appealing but the stairs were in poor shape. I saw one elderly woman almost fall down. Second-floor rooms would be difficult or impossible for someone handicapped. 
The rooms were not thoroughly cleaned and there was a lack of supplies like toilet paper. I am not sure if these rooms were for extended stay, but they did not seem to fit what I was expecting from Wyndham West in Columbus. The one positive note about the hotel was the superior breakfast, but, the room was often dirty and not quickly cleaned from guests.