Nice, traditional hotel in a great location!
I have just gotten back from NYC, watching the US Open. During my stay the lobby entrance which connects it to the main lobby/reception was being restored. Not a problem, and after all, is was worth seeing it brand new!
I had an upgrade to a jr. suite and it was amazing. Lots of space for luggage, desk, drawers everywhere, eletronic safe, tv in both room and living room. Bathroom was OK, but I found it a little too small for a 5* standard.
Everyone at the front desk was always thoughtful and helpful towards all my needs. So was the bell service. Housekeeping did its job well everyday.
Good thing about the hotel is its location. It sits on an entire block between Park Avenue and Lexington Avenue, and 49th and 50th. (49th is the only street with no access to the hotel).
You can just walk to 5th Avenue or even to Times Square.
I wont't give this hotel a 5* rating because everything is way too expensive (USD 16 for a bottle of water, for example).
if you are looking for a traditional hotel with good service, great location and lots of glamour, this hotel will easily fit your needs. It has so much history that you can even have a tour of the hotel with breakfast included (cost of USD 50 per person, of course).