Great to have space in NYC, helpful staff
I booked a studio with kitchenette and small lounge room and it was so great to have space to myself. It's so close to Penn Station, Madison Square Garden, Macy's and an easy walk to broadway and times square. Great location for first time visitors. The room service salad and burger i had during my stay were delicious though it is expensive. The staff in the bar are great and only too happy to recommend restaurants and what nights to head where. And the guest services were always available to handle any questions, including organising a FedEx to ship my shoe purchases home.
The walls are a little thin, and you do get street noise at all hours (it is New York). You may want to ask for a higher floor to minimise the street noise (I was on level 10). 
I wouldn't hesitate to stay here again or try any of the other Affinia hotels.