Overall a great place to stay!
My husband and I stayed at the Edgewater in Seattle for three nights about a month ago. We selected this hotel based on the location and previous reviews. When we arrived, our check-in process went very smoothly. The staff is exceptionally welcoming; everyone smiles and appears to really enjoy being there! Our room was a bit on the small side, but it did have a small patio with adirondack chairs, which was a surprise to me. We had amazing views of the downtown skyline as well as the bay. Luckily, it was clear and we could also see Mount Ranier. Unfortunately, the smell of the nearby piers wafted into our room (smelled of gasoline) and gave me a slight headache. The rooms were very nice, but the bathroom was amazing. The stonework in the shower was impressive and made my husband want to do that to our bathroom at home! One downside about the room was that the light above the shower kept going out, so it was a little dark. 
Throughout our stay we utilized several services including the workout facilities, shuttle services, and restaurant. The exercise room is small with a couple treadmills and ellipticals. Also, the view is a little unpleasant. The shuttle services were great - at no cost we were able to get a ride to Pioneer Square and walk back. The restaurant and bar was also very nice, but it was a little spendy. One evening, my husband and I played Scrabble in the lobby while enjoying hot drinks watching the sunset over the bay. This was very nice and a memorable part of our trip. 
A few criticisms I have is that the cost of WiFi is $10 for each device! We opted not to use this service due to the cost. Instead, we went down the street to Starbucks and used the free WiFi. Lastly, the cost of parking is quite expensive. 
Overall, it was a very positive experience. I would stay here again!