A 2 star property
I'm a frequent traveler to NYC. I took my goddaughter over St. Patrick's Day weekend and my normal hotels were booked, so I tried the Hilton Garden Inn. We had a double queen room. Yes, it's New York, but these rooms are uncomfortably small, even for New York, and a bit cheap and sad looking. The staff was fine and the elevators were swift, but this is very much a cut below a normal Hilton and to be honest, not a very good value given the so-so location, lack of amenities and room size. New York has many more hotels that are better values for your money, and I'm not talking the astronomical 4 - 5 stars that are above $500/night. If you go with lowered expectations of 2 star hotel and get a good deal, it's fine I suppose, but I would definitely never stay there again.