Great Setting, Courteous Staff and Meeting Rooms, Dilapidated Sleeping Rooms...
I recently drove down the coast for a professional association meeting at Kona Kai. The weather was warm, the marina setting was beautiful, the meeting went smoothly, and then there were the guest rooms. My appears concurred that the rooms had a "wet musty" smell to them, the wall unit air conditioners were loud, and didn't smell clean, the bathrooms were dark, and the beds very soft. When you drive into the main entrance, the hotel looks recently remodeled. Unfortunately, this has not trickled to the guest rooms. I would not select this property for business stay (it is on Shelter Island), or for a conference only due to the sleeping rooms. The staff was wonderful, the restaurant was good, and the setting priceless...please upgrade your guest rooms....I want to come back.