It's Alright
I was expecting more out of this hotel based on its TrpAdv rating. I would definitely put this place at 3 out 5. Average is the word that comes to mind. AND should you stay here, ask for a room away from 39th & Lex. I was on the 6st floor over the intersection and it was LOUD. It did not prevent me from sleeping, as I'm not a light sleeper, but it was distracting at times.
Check In/Out was quick. The staff was not exactly friendly, nor rude. Sort of indifferent.
The room itself was spacious/350 sq ft. The bed was a nice comfortable king with nice pillows. However, the head board is covered in black cloth, which had nasty looking stains on it. (Food? Something nastier? EEEW!) The room looked clean until I went to plug in my lap top and noticed thick dust under the desk around the fixtures. The nightstand had part of it's finish worn off. Very 2nd hand and used looking. The baseboards were sloppily and unattractively sealed in places. The tiles in the bathroom had discoloration between them. 
I don't intend to make The Court sound horrible. All of these things were minor to me...with exception of the stains on the headboard! But I did notice. I had expected much better given the hotel's reputation. It's not a place I would seek out on a return visit to NYC. Though, the neighborhood is nice, and if I found a decent deal (Pd $120 + tax thru booking.com) I'd consider it. But only after checking other options. Not exactly a memorable experience.