Location, location, location
We stayed at the Kona Kai in a third floor room, king bed, balcony with marina view. I would rate the hotel average+ largely due to it's beautiful location on Shelter Island. The room was ok, clean, but somewhat dated. Free wifi was nice. Outdoor heated Pool is large with some lap lanes and a nice spa. There is a sand "sunning" beach with playground equipment, nice for children. You can walk or run on a path along the water's edge. We had breakfast once at the hotel restaurant. Background music is Hawaiian and very pleasant. Food and service were good but there were not many diners so it's hard to say what it would be like when busier. The parking lot for guests is gated, requiring a room key swipe to open gate when entering and exiting. The device at the exit gate must have been hit by a vehicle because it is bent lower than a car window, and difficult to swipe. It should be repaired.