Great Value!
My husband and I were staying for just one night on a trip down to San Diego and booked the Bay Club through Hotwire. Recieved a great deal on this hotel and read many of the great reviews. The breakfast was outstanding as I had previously read from others & the marina and bay views really nice. The staff at the front desk could not have been anything but nice and helpful. Though our room which was at the very end on the first floor was something to be desired. We overlooked out to a parking area and side walkway to the marina side. Could see a little of the bay. Room had paint peeling in certain areas, covered light fixture shade torn and old expired San Diego magazines. King bed was comfortable, but the pillows were not. Now maybe we recieved that room because of the deal we recieved on Hotwire and that we were staying for just one night. Seems that this hotel is older than the other three hotels on Shelter Island and might just need a little renovation. Love the location and Shelter Island!