Give it four stars for location and deduct three for everything else
21 floors of tired looking 1950's style motel rooms, with poor service and false advertising: you know, where they say there's a pool but you get there and it is "under maintenance" and you ask around and the pool has been "under maintenance" for weeks? So, you already know you paid too much for facilities that aren't available because you choose this one out of the hundred you could pick from because it had a pool (which, by the way, wasn't operative when you booked though you wouldn't know that from the web site).. Then you get a bill on check-out when you've prepaid which you confirmed at check in and you are told "oh, we're sorry, we have a new data system" but you really feel that they are only correcting it because you caught it. So many choices in NY: don't make this one.