Good, but dated
We wanted to stay in a hotel in Manhattan, and found this hotel online - offering 2 queen beds, and only 5 minutes on the subway to Times Square.
The hotel room was dated (artwork and bedding) but very clean and the staff was helpful. The neighbourhood was great and it was near the reservoir in Central Park - which made for a nice walk.
My biggest complaint was that despite some obvious updating, the room had a VERY loud window mounted air conditioner. We were forced to sleep with the AC unit running, or else the room was too hot (since you could not open the window because of the AC unit), and it made for a disturbing sleep. For that reason alone I would not recommend the hotel, and would not return. Should they install newer, quiet units in the future I would definitely stay there again.
Also - an in-room safe would be a nice addition.