Acceptable but nothing special
My husband and I stayed at the Renaissance NY Hotel 57 for our honeymoon mid-August this year. Our room was small but very clean and had a spacious washroom. The staff often ignored us (likely because we're younger? We're both 25) but we found the bellhop to be the most pleasant person at the hotel. The location was great if you want to do a lot of shopping. We likely would not stay there again because we did not feel very welcomed by the staff.