Outstanding Engagement Trip
First off, let me start by saying that I am a very seasoned worldwide traveler and this hotel & the staff outperform any other hotel I've ever stayed in. The service from check in to check out was impeccable, the restaurant was fantastic and the location was perfect. You're within walking distance of 2, maybe 3 El Train stops (that I can remember) and the Magnificent Mile. You can also hop on the free trolley (across the street from the hotel) that goes to the Navy Pier. The rooms are modern, spacious, spotlessly clean and so comfortable. My fiancee and I came to celebrate our engagement for 3 nights and we both cannot wait to return to Chicago and stay at the Palomar again. We arrived super early at the hotel after landing at Midway (due to a 1pm Cubs game), dropped our bags with the concierge and headed to the Cubs game. When we arrived back at the hotel after the game, our room was ready immediately and we were situated within 5 minutes. At a time when traveling can be nightmarish, and hotels skimp in every way possible, it was so refreshing to stay at a hotel where nearly anything you may need during your stay is not out of the question. It's extremely pleasant to have a staff who never feels inconvenienced because you, as a tourist, are asking for their suggestions, or directions. Exceptional customer service propels the Palomar into the lead. The Palomar Chicago is no doubt a fantastic choice. I cannot emphasize enough how wonderful this hotel was. 
Here's my two cents- Stop reading the tripadvisor reviews for other hotels in Chicago and just book the Palomar. You won't regret it. OH, and it's also within walking distance to Lou Malnati's Pizzeria, which is heaven on earth.