Great all around
Was a bit concerned after booking given its negative reviews of the location, posh styling, and small rooms, but everything went very well. This was our first time to NYC, wanted to do touristy things, but also wanted a newer hotel that didnt cost an arm and a leg.
After our flight we decided to take the bus and the subway instead of a cab, which may or may not have been a great decision as it was pouring the whole time. We arrived at the hotel around 1030am drenched. I'm typically afraid to check in so early do to past experiences, but was hoping I could sweet talk myself into a room. Well no sweet talking needed, without even checking the young lady said she will find me a room, that bumps this place from 4-5 stars.
I was sick for the entire vacation, and didnt leave the room for 36 hours. So unfortanetly, I became very well acquanited with the hotel room. Yes, it was small, but it was as large as I expected for NYC and did the trick. Bathroom was large and had great water pressure. We stayed on the 16th floor and didnt hear any of the noise from the 5th floor, also construction noise was minimal. 
There are numerous L stops within a few blocks that will get you wherever you want to go. Also a very nice view of the statue of liberty a few blocks away too