Underwhelming
Pros: The lobby looks really cool with the style of an old jail. The champagne upon checking in was a nice touch. 
I expected a lot as I went up to my room. 
The lobby portion is in what used to be the actual jail and the bulk of the rooms are in a separate building right behind the jail building. Of course it is connected though. There are only 18 rooms in the actual 'jail'. The rest are in the new building, which is where our room was.
Cons: The room was completely underwhelming. They should at least somehow decorate it or make it relate to the whole jail theme, yet you walk into a completely generic hotel room. It looks so basic too, it's definitely not worth the price they charge. We got this room for free with our Starwood points but if we had to spend $500 on that room there would have been some serious problems.
The view from the window looked out onto the "lovely" hospital wall which is right next to the hotel. 
Trying to get a good nights sleep was out of the question. After a long day of walking around, all I wanted to do was sleep yet kept being awakened every half hour by loud people walking back to their room. Every time I would finally drift off to sleep, I was startled awake by the sound of rowdiness in the hallways. This lasted between the hours of 12AM and 5AM. The hotel needs to implement some sort of rule of keeping quiet when walking through the hallways in the middle of the night. It was ridiculous.
Would I recommend this hotel to someone else? No. It's not worth what they charge. Completely overpriced. Go to any number of better hotels in the area that probably charge the same or less, with much better amenities, better views, and a better nights sleep.