Lots of good and bad
My wife and l stayed here for 4 nights in the spring of 2012, and my overall impression is mixed. Great location! Penn Station, Macys, Herald Squre, tons of great restaurants and the Empire State Building are all within a block of here. There is a subway stop almost right outside the door as well. The staff was great, and it was very quiet. You would never know your in mid-town Manhatten until you looked out your window it was that quiet. However, the room was small and smelled bad. I think the smell was due to the air mattress they use. The room we had did not have a bathtub either.. But hey... its New York... who cares about the size of the room. I would recommend to stay in a floor as high as possible