Ehhhh OK.
As a fellow New Yorker - I love staying at different hotels in the city. Call it a mini-staycation. My bf and I stayed at this hotel for a night and my overall feeling is ehhh. We had the standard room. I'd give this hotel 2-3 stars. We had issues with our AC. Room felt humid and we couldn't figure out why. They sent a repair guy twice?? but didn't really do anything. He did try though. Room itself wasn't too impressive, nothing stood out, average room. Looked old. Bed was comfy. Location was good. The reason why I gave it 2 stars is: price $450 for the night was just ridiculous. For that amount we were really looking forward for an awesome room. I really thought it was going to be a modern looking room, but it just looked like a kids bedroom. Didn't meet our expectation. If you're looking for just a place to stay, you can probably find a cheaper hotel.