A Passing Grade - Barely
When my first choice airport hotel was sold out, I was forced to activate Plan B. Deterred by traveler reviews – not to mention the $150 rate + parking– I steered clear of the Courtyard Old Town. I settled on the Fairfield Inn Old town which was $40 cheaper. The hotel is conveniently located blocks from I-5 but far enough where the noise does not come into play.
The façade is typical Old Town architecture, and there is a pleasant interior courtyard and pool. The guest room was standard Fairfield. My room faced San Diego Avenue, but this was a non-issue. However, I would recommend an interior-facing room for the visual appeal. The amenities are also standard Fairfield. The gym has two treadmills, a stairmaster, and a bicycle, all of which are brand new. Wireless internet and a continental breakfast are complimentary. The only ancillary fee is $15 for parking. Given that parking is a premium in Old Town, the fee is acceptable. If you’re looking to save on parking, you can play parking roulette and search for a street spot.
While the aesthetics made me think I was at a more upscale property, several items reminded me that this was still a Fairfield Inn. First, I arrived shortly after 5pm and was fifth in line to check in. There was one gentleman working the front desk. Despite his best efforts to keep the line moving, he was only one person. Second, the shower did not drain, and the tide rose to several inches. Third, there was a pink discoloration next to the drain. Coupled with a couple spots on the towel, this does not evoke a sense of cleanliness. Finally, this hotel uses next generation electronic keys. The associate informed me there would be a $1 charge if the key was not returned, so I begrudgingly stopped by the front desk to check out. The bill was also not delivered to my room – perhaps so guests don’t walk away with the precious key cards – so it was a mandatory trip. The nuisance turned to annoyance after stepping in gum next to the front desk. I’ll repeat for emphasis – I stepped in gum which had been deposited on the hotel lobby floor. 
In summary, I really wanted to like this Fairfield Inn. The hotel has character, and location is ideal. While I would overlook any one of the aforementioned issues, the sum forces me to rate this hotel as average. Take away the Spanish façade and the renovation, and this hotel would not earn a passing mark. 
Pros: Hotel façade – Spanish architecture typical of Old Town
Cons: Several minor issues bring overall rating to average