Huge boutique hotel (with small rooms) in NYC
If you look on their website for the room descriptions, it will say that the standard Single and Double rooms are 167 square feet. That's not a typo. The rooms are small. Even at that size, they have everything you could need- full bathroom (including a tub!) a desk, a closet and comfy bed. The staff is exceedingly friendly and helpful- even though the hotel is huge, it always felt like I was in a boutique hotel. All the amenities you could need are there- every floor has a "concierge closet" (which is really just vending and ice machines, but still super-convenient if you need something immediately. The hotel is at the southern tip of Central Park, and near lots of drug stores, restaurants and coffee shops. 
My only complaints (and they are much smaller than the rooms) the restaurant- Hudson Hall was only so-so (I got there at the tail-end of breakfast, but everyone was still very accomodating even though there wasn't a great food selection). And the water pressure in the shower was low- the bathrooms definitely need new showerheads.