Recommended!
If you are looking for a comfortable, clean yet basic place to stay at a 'budget' price whilst in the Big Apple, I recommend the Larchmont. 
The location is superb and on a quiet street. I had a room on the 3rd floor facing the street and had no problems with noise...in fact it was pretty quiet. 
Pros: Comfortable bed, basin, ceiling fan and tv in the rooms, shared bathrooms clean, free internet, nice lobby, helpful staff, elevator, free breakfast...
Cons: couldn't really think of any to be honest! Some guests may scoff at what is offered for breakfast, though I was grateful for toast, orange juice, coffee.
I would definitely stay here again