Friendly Hotel Staff
Good location - within minutes to two different subway lines, Madison Square Park (where they have a Shake Shack), Eataly, and retail shops.
Small room - upon reading previous reviews, we knew that rooms were small and they are. However, the bed is really comfortable and the bathroom is of decent size. Due to the small space, the room didn't have a fridge which we thought would be nice to keep our water cool.
Friendly staff - they were courteous and helpful. Accommodated to our request for a quiet room (higher floor, facing the back). On our last night, we woke up around 1:30am to some partiers (it was the fourth of July) and had to call front desk about it. About a minute later, the noise eased so we were able to go back to sleep. 
We would stay here again at our next trip.