Clean and comfortable, but big and busy
I'd give it 3.5 stars if I could. We got a good rate on this hotel through an internet site. It was very convenient to Penn Station, and perfect for us since we took the Amtrak into NYC. This is a big, busy hotel with lots of tourists. The rooms were small, but recently redone and comfortable. The bed and pillow were great, and there was free wireless and good cable t.v. We were about 10 blocks from Time Square, so it was an easy walk to the theatre district but far enough away to avoid the noise and crowds if you want to. For the price we paid, this was a good deal, but I would have been disappointed if I had paid the posted rates.