Expected more
I just completed a 3 night stay for pleasure. The standard king room was comfortable in size (by NYC standards!) but extremely dark. There were a few lamps, but even when all of them were on, the room was still fairly dark. Only one side of the bed had a reading lamp above it. We were on the second floor on the 6th Avenue side and noise was not a problem. I sleep with earplugs, so the noise from the nightclub downstairs wasn't a problem for me, but you can definitely hear it without the earplugs! 
I found it very odd that there was no top sheet on the bed. I don't know if this was specific to our room and an oversight, but the duvet-covered down comforter was all we had. I didn't notice until our 3rd evening and didn't bother to say anything to the staff at that point. Also very odd is the single bar of soap in the bathroom. This serves serve both the sink area and the shower. Very unusual to have to move the soap from one area to the other. I thought we'd get another bar the next day, but only had that one bar for sink and shower for the duration of our stay. Again, I didn't complain, but I found it very curious. The sink area is very industrial and stainless steel. It gives off the feeling of washing up in a commercial kitchen sink!
I only ate breakfast in the hotel lobby restaurant. Half a cup of Greek yogurt, some fresh berries, a glass of orange juice and jasmine tea totaled $31 (gratuity included). A bit steep, but it's NYC and a hotel, so it's to be expected. The wait staff was attentive and friendly.
I only had contact once with the concierge and he scolded me for demagnetizing my room key. He told me "they give you the pouch for a reason". 
The location is fantastic because it's close enough to walk to Soho, without all the crowds and noise. Tribeca is loaded with great restaurants, so dining options are plenty in the area of the hotel.
All in all, I'd probably stay here again if the rate was good. I can't imagine staying for an extended period of time though. The darkness of it was a bit depressing.