Great
This was my first time in NYC and The Jane and I will definitely be back. The room was small but it had everything in it that I needed and was comfortable. I had no problem with noise as other people have reported. I thought the location was really good for basically getting anywhere in the city as the subway is so close but I also walked to a lot of places to get to take it all in. The neighbourhood the hotel is in is also really nice and feels like a village and a lot quiet than further uptown but there is still a lot going on. The staff were really friendly and helpful. Also ordered room service one night and the food was great and arrived quickly. Another unexpected bonus was that you could see the Statue of Liberty out of the bathroom window on fourth floor and the view at night was really nice. I think if you're looking for a base to explore the city from then this is the perfect place.