Can't wait to return!
Spent 4 nights in NY, 3 of them at this hotel and it was great. The woman that checked us in was so helpful and very friendly. And each staff person we came across throughout our stay, be it front desk, housekeeping, security, restaurant, etc. - everyone was very friendly. If you're unfamiliar with NY or the area, please take advantage of the front desk. They know the city well and are very willing to help out.
The rooms are comfortable. We were on the 5th floor and our room faced the street, which we enjoyed thoroughly. You're in Manhattan, so if you're concerned about street noise I would suggest requesting a room on a higher floor and away from the street.
The hotel is centrally located near many trains that can get you anywhere in the city. It's also close enough to many great restaurants and shops that you may not even need a train. During our stay, we used the train just twice and were able to walk everywhere else.
Thanks for a great stay, Courtyard!