If everything was like the lobby...
I had the worst experience in an hotel ever. I know, the location is very good, in front of Madison Square Garden, just a couple of blocks from Macys, Empire State, and so. We had a early arrival, so we receive a tag for keep our bags at their basement, nice touch. We went to the bathrooms at the basement, and are very very dirty and smells very bad. The lobby and the people walking thru make you feel that you are in very well hotel, old hotel, but kind of clean and nice or fancy.
When the time to check-in came, the eternal walk to our room make me feel like I was walking in an abandoned ship, or building. The carpets were old, dirty and smelly. The doors were the original from 1917. The walls are dirty. The bathroom was decent, and clean. The room itself it was a little bit scary and smelly. Our room was big with a little tv set. The hotel needs a restoration urgently.