Stay here if you want to get experience as if you are in 1912!
I choose this hotel without looking at the reviews but thought it would be a good one because it's bang opposite Penn Station and from outside it looks decent.
You get into a lobby, it looks like you are in grand central, too big and too many people, and while checking in it took me 45 minutes. The room doors are probably 100 yr old like vault rooms, bath room is also probably 70-80 years old. The bed is ok but room is small.
The best price about this hotel is rate, if you are looking for something less then $130/night, this is the place to stay :)