Convenient but nothing special
We had an afternoon flight in but check in wasn't until 4 (we'd been hoping to rearrange, get our bearings, and change). We were able to store our luggage, thankfully. 
Rooms are very small but clean. We were tripping over our luggage and hitting the sharp corners in the bathroom. Room cleaning service was done daily. However, we had to request toilet paper twice, and once it didn't arrive until after we'd left for the day. We had a newly rennovated room (I requested such when booking and also requested a room with a view, which we kind of had). The hallways are very dark and dingy (can't find that particular pic atm).
Concierge was difficult to get a hold of pre-trip and had inconvenient hours while we were there. 
Security was only out front one of the 5 nights we were there. 
t was conveniently located a few short blocks from Times Square, most of the theaters, and from one of the major subway stations, connecting to all lines. 
Not having an onsite restaurant was a little inconvenient but several delis and a Starbucks are within a few hundred feet. 
The morning we left we realized we didn't have any cash to tip the bell hop after we were loaded into the taxi. He actually screamed at us as we were pulling away.
This review gets a 3 only because of location.