This is your choice!
I stayed here in February. Have to say the location could not be better a 2 minute walk to Time Square and a 5 minute walk to 5th Avenue. The rooms are clean and for NY are a good size. 
The staff in the hotel are very well trained and showed excellent customer service every time I dealt with them.
When I return to NY ,I will be staying at Sanctuary and I would recommend anyone else who visits NY to do the same.