Nice Elegant Old style hotel
I Went for pleasure/business trip to NY. The hotel is a nice luxury hotel, I found it old style, not a modern hotel, which gives it a nice touch when visiting NY. The rooms are big and comfortable, that was surprising for a NYC hotel where usually space is an issue. Location next to St. Patrick and walking from 5th avenue is excellent. 
I thought breakfast was a little bit expensive. I didn't like that the lobby was always full of people, there was a lot of movement all day and till late at night. 
Something to be careful is the Do not disturb is a button right under the lights so if you forget to turn it off or press it by accident when turning lights of before leaving (It happened to me), your room will obviously not be cleaned all day, I don't think it's that practical and I think it's easier just to have the regular sign hanging.
In general I would recommend this hotel to get a feel of NY.