Meh
Everything at this hotel just misses the mark. 
Their website list square footage for each type of room, but they seem to very generous in their measurements. We checked into #39, which was supposed to be 200 sq ft, but I think 150 would have been closer to the mark (and I'd guess about 40 of that is bathroom). We ended up paying for an upgrade to #86 (even though it was on a smoking "optional" floor). #86 was listed at 300 sq. ft, but it felt like it was barely over 200.
Closet and drawer space very limited. Ended up with my suicase on the window sill.
Bathtub/shower was also really narrow. Nice toiletries, but no shower gel. Bathroom lighting too fluorescent/unnatural.
HVAC really noisy, so we turned it off most of the time (OK in spring, but wouldn't work in summer or winter).
Sound from the shower in the adjacent room also very loud.
Decor dark and gloomy.
On the plus side - service was pleasant, location it excellent. 
But I wouldn't stay here again - there are lots of better options in NYC.