Quaint and homey, yet has a real old Broadway and Television Star feel.
I felt like I was staying in the lap of luxury, because of the fine treatment by the staff and the feeling I got ,from the decorations and decor, that many stars of Broadway and Television had stayed there. Being from central Illinois and being over 60 years old, and being in NY for the first time, I was in awe of the feel of old Hollywood or Broadway in the lobby, the hallways and the room we stayed in. I don't think the price was bad for the comfort of the room. Yes, it was small, but we didn't need a lot of room to sleep, and that is about all we did there.....I LOVE NEW YORK. The location is excellent! Even my old legs could easily make it to most of the attractions in the area and there is bicycle rental next door and a cathedral across the street and TWO theaters in the same block. 
We stayed two nights in room 205 with King bed (very comfy bed). Free Internet too. Iron and ironing board in the room and a safe located behind a beautiful wall desk/ cabinet. Large bathroom and a bathtub big enough to soak in, so bring your bubblebath ladies! 
Can't comment on the elevator, as we used the stairs. The carpet does need to be replaced in the lobby and the hallways, but the room was clean and bright. I wish the owner would consider opening the restaurant area, at least for coffee and drinks.
I will recommend the Mayfair to anyone who likes atmosphere over chrome and glaring lights.
BTW, don't forget to tip the staff! They don't ask for it, but they are so nice and they deserve it.