For that price is the worst choice
We booked for three people and once we reached the hotel we realized that the room had just one bed. We asked for an extra bed and the looked surprised about that, then when we checked out, we were charged $ 50 more per day for the extra bed. Adding taxes and charges, we paid over $ 600 a day for the room, without even having breakfast. For that price, there are many better hotels in NYC, such as the New York Palace Hotel, with real professional workers, and very close to this, in fact better placed and with better views too.
The only thing good is the Gotham Hotel is the location. Moreover, there is no reception, workers do not wear uniforms and when you do check in, literally, you don’t know who you'll meet or where. The workers are young and good willing but lack the professionalism of a hotel of this price.
Trust me, there are many better hotels in NYC for that price.